Okay, I guess I don't know squat. I'm only a fricking children's librarian who has spent 20 years working with kids and reading basically every piece of fiction that comes into my library.
And I guess I'm just an overprotective, overanxious mother who wants to wrap her little girls in bubble wrap until they're 18 and out the door.
Actually, I'm not, and such parents tend to drive me up the wall. Especially when it seems that they do so until about the age of 16, at which time they give them the keys to an SUV, let them out the door and wail "but he/she is SO responsible!" to the reporters after the kid has smashed up the car while DUI.........
But it is my firm opinion that anyone who is handing this book to a kid younger than 10 or 11 isn't reading them themselves. Or is the sort of parent who lets their kids watch R rated movies, has no problem with anything they watch on TV and doesn't screen their video games!
The first few books had a good deal of fun in them. There were always funny bits with the Dursleys, with Hagrid's magical creatures, with Neville Longbottom muffing up again, or with the Weasley's pranks.
But this is a DARK, DARK, DARK book. It is not full of laughs and fun. The first chapter is set in the Prime Minister's office and is as dark and gloomy and political as a lot of the blogs that depress me. Rowling's magical wizard world is an eerie reflection of the world we are living in right now. Obviously, she could not have anticipated the horror of 7/11 at King's Cross Station, yet the annual magical departure of the Hogwarts Express could easily be happening on Platform 9 or 10 of the Muggle world. It is that joyless and fearful.
Even the Quidditch games tend to end with disasters. There is next to no comic relief!
And the boy-girl story lines (no spoilers here) seem pretty pointless and flat.
For that matter has anyone but me noticed how Victorian Harry Potter is? I mean the movies definitely caught the impression from the text as if time had stopped sometime around 1880 in terms of furniture, decor, etc in the Wizard world.
But the characters all seem quite Victorian too. I mean, here we are in the 6th book dealing with 16-17 year olds who should be raging with hormones. All together in a co-ed boarding school and the only thing that appears to be going on is mild "snogging"!
Hey, is that what makes Harry P. okay to read to your 5 year old? I mean there's killings, violence, evil lurking everywhere, monsters in every closet, but there's NO SEX!
Fine and dandy then. Read away. Enjoy.
Like I said, what the hell do I know? I'm just a children's librarian. What would I know about BOOKS?